Menu

Our Bagels & Cream Cheese

HOUSEMADE • ALL-NATURAL • HANDCRAFTED

Our Famous Bagels

PLAIN • EVERYTHING • ASIAGO CHEESE • SESAME • CINNAMON RAISIN • ONION HONEY GRAIN • BLUEBERRY • JALAPEÑO • SUPER CINNAMON RAISIN • POPPY • SEA SALT • CHOCOLATE CHIP • MARBLE • GARLIC • FRENCH TOAST • 100% WHOLE WHEAT • 100% WHOLE WHEAT SESAME, POPPY, EVERYTHING

Cream Cheese

PLAIN • GARDEN SCALLION • JALAPEÑO • STRAWBERRY • SWEET CINNAMON RAISIN • OLIVE & CHIVE • ROASTED RED PEPPER • LITE PLAIN

Breakfast

Served All Day

Naked Bagel

Our house made cream cheese or other topping on a freshly baked bagel. Simply perfect.

  • w/ Cream Cheese
  • w/ Peanut Butter
  • w/ Butter
  • w/ Jelly

Traditional Press

Egg, bacon, smoked ham & cheddar cheese on a grilled bagel.

VEGGIE OMELETTE

Egg & cheddar cheese mixed with seasonal vegetables on a bagel.

Phoenix Press

Egg, black bean salsa, tomato, avocado & cheddar cheese grilled on a jalapeño bagel.

KALAMATA PRESS

Egg, feta spread, olive tapenade & tomato grilled on harvest wheat bread.

The Patriot

Grilled steak, egg & pepper jack cheese on a bagel.

Bagels & Cream Cheese Cluster

A baker’s dozen of Finagle’s Artisan Bagels and 2 tubs of cream cheese.

Cholesterol-free eggs available upon request.

Sandwiches

SMOKED SALMON & CREAM CHEESE

Smoked salmon, tomato, red onion & cream cheese on a handcrafted bagel.

TUNA MELT

Tuna salad, tomato, cheddar cheese & avocado.

CHIPOTLE CHICKEN BACON MELT

Grilled chicken breast, bacon, tomato, pepper jack cheese & our signature chipotle mayo.

SANTA FE MELT

Smoked turkey, avocado, spicy black beans, pepper jack cheese & pepperberry sauce on a jalapeño bagel.

FIRST STREET CHICKEN SALAD

Chicken salad, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce & our special sauce on a plain bagel.

ROAST BEEF CLUB

Roast Beef, bacon, BBQ chips, roasted red pepper spread, lettuce, tomato and pickles on our housemade focaccia.

GRILLED CHICKEN

Grilled chicken breast, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo & honey mustard.

CLASSIC BLT

Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo on toasted country white bread.

Vegetarian Favorites

Boston Garden This item is vegetarian

Hummus, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, red onion, olive-feta tapenade & balsamic vinaigrette served on harvest wheat bread.

Caprese This item is vegetarian

Fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, pesto & balsamic vinaigrette on our housemade focaccia.

TOMATO CHEDDAR MELT This item is vegetarian

Tomato, avocado, honey mustard & cheddar cheese on a bagel of your choice.

GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH This item is vegetarian

Served on our housemade bread.

This item is vegetarian = vegetarian



The Basics

Served on your choice of a bagel or bread. All sandwiches are served with tomato and lettuce.

  • ROASTED TURKEY
  • Roast Beef
  • Egg Salad
  • Smoked Turkey *
  • Chicken Salad
  • Hummus
  • Smoked Ham
  • Tuna Salad

* Nitrate-free

  • Add-Ons
  • Red Onion
  • CUCUMBERS
  • PICKLES
  • PEPPERS
  • MAYO
  • CHIPOTLE MAYO
  • HONEY MUSTARD
  • DIJON MUSTARD
  • SRIRACHA SAUCE
  • Add-Ons
  • AVOCADO
  • BACON
  • CHEDDAR CHEESE
  • PEPPER JACK CHEESE
  • SWISS CHEESE
  • CREAM CHEESE SCHMEAR
  • OLIVE FETA TAPENADE

Pizza Bagels

PEPPERONI PIZZA BAGEL

Topped with marinara sauce, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese.

Salads

FIESTA GRANDE

Grilled chicken, Romaine lettuce, shredded pepper jack cheese, black bean salsa, avocado, grape tomatoes & spicy bagel strips. Smoked jalapeño dressing

MEDITERRANEAN SALAD This item is vegetarian

Romaine lettuce, olives, feta, grape tomatoes, red & orange peppers, cucumbers & red onion. Greek dressing

THE COBB

Romaine lettuce, bacon, hard-boiled egg, crumbly blue cheese, avocado, grape tomatoes & red onion. Balsamic vinaigrette or blue cheese dressing

CHICKEN CAESAR

Grilled chicken, Romaine lettuce & Parmesan cheese. Creamy Caesar dressing

All salads are served with our housemade bagel chips.
Dressing Options: Smoked Jalapeno, Greek, Creamy Caesar, Blue Cheese, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Low-fat Honey Dijon

Soups

Soup as a Meal

A large bowl of our gourmet soup. Served with our housemade challah!

GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH + SMALL SOUP

The perfect combination. Served on our housemade bread.

Small Soup

Add a cup of soup to any lunch item.

  • Our Soups
  • CREAMY TOMATO
  • CHICKEN SOUP
  • BEEF CHILI
  • BROCCOLI CHEDDAR
  • N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
  • SPLIT PEA This item is vegetarian

What We Bake

At The Test Kitchen

We bake all of our breads, scones, muffins, cakes, cookies and other goodies fresh daily at our Test Kitchen in Newton. We try new recipes, flavors and varieties on our guests at the Test Kitchen before rolling them out. We have outdoor seating and plenty of free parking.

Come by and test our what we are baking up today and watch our bagel bakers baking up today’s bagels.
Open Daily 6AM-6PM

Bagels

Muffins

Cookies

Scones

Half Moons

Macaroons

Lemon Bundt Cakes

Chocolate Bundt Cakes

Challah

Beverages

Hot Coffee

Finagle’s Roast, Hazelnut, French Vanilla and Decaf

Iced Coffee

Finagle’s Roast, Hazelnut, French Vanilla and Decaf

Iced Tea

Unsweetened Regular, Peach or Raspberry or sweetened with Cane Syrup

Hot Tea

Earl Gray, English Breakfast, Green or Herbal

Hot Chocolate

Rich & Creamy Milk Chocolate topped with Whipped Cream

Fountain Beverages

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper and Fanta Orange

Before placing your order, please inform your server if anyone in your party has a food allergy.